top of page
Image by Timothy Hales Bennett

Online Community Platforms

My dissertation project delved into the unique experiences of bicultural individuals and their intangible cultural heritage. The project's ultimate goal was to provide valuable design guidelines and implications for online community platforms to better support bicultural individuals when sharing and preserving their heritage.

collaborators

Individual Project

project duration

24 April 2023 → 14 August 2023

project type

Research Project

Participatory Design Research

key skills

user interviews

transcription

coding

thematic analysis

co-design workshop

literature analysis

data synthesis

research report

scope of study

This study investigates the challenges and opportunities British-born Chinese (BBC) individuals face when sharing their cultural heritage through online community platforms. Through interviews with BBC individuals, I aimed to understand their sense of cultural identity, their engagement in their heritage, and their online platform use regarding intangible cultural heritage. This study also utilised participatory co-design methods in a workshop with community members to develop guidelines and possible design solutions for online platforms. Using Reflexive Thematic Analysis, interview and workshop findings were collectively reported with autoethnographic insights. Evidence shares the challenges that BBCs face when utilising online community platforms and further develops design guidelines and implications to enrich meaningful experiences through online platforms.

method

This study utilises three approaches to address the research questions; autoethnography, interviews, and a co-design workshop. Each method offered unique perspectives, providing a holistic understanding of BBCs' challenges and opportunities with online platforms. Combining these three methods allowed me to take an insider approach to the research whilst also involving community members in the research process.

Ethical Considerations

  • Ethical approval obtained 

  • Information sheet provided to inform the participants about the research

  • Consent forms

Autoethnography

  • Notes and insights recorded from being a member of a BBC Online Community on Facebook

Interviews

  • Conducted interviews to explore personal experiences of bicultural individuals (BBCs)

  • Investigated the role of social media in supporting cultural heritage sharing

  • Explored participants' recognition of their cultural heritage and connection to it

  • Examined how social media influenced participants' sense of belonging in their community

  • Interview questions covered experiences, cultural identity, and social media use related to cultural heritage

Co-design Workshop

  • Developed an online 2-hour co-design workshop based on insights, challenges, and opportunities from interviews

  • Leveraged participatory design methods to address key challenges in online community platforms

  • Workshop aimed to create guidelines and design features for sharing various cultural heritages

Data Analysis

  • Thematic analysis of interview transcript data

  • Generation of final themes from coded data

  • Four main themes gathered from interviews

Copy of BBC Cultural Heritage Workshop - Persona 2.jpg
Copy of BBC Cultural Heritage Workshop - Persona 1.jpg

results

Through a thematic analysis, codes were created from interview transcripts. Codes were grouped and associated to create the four main themes.

Theme 1: An Evolving Sense of Cultural Identity

  • Participants' upbringing in predominantly white environments led to a more British and Westernised cultural identity.

  • The pressure to fit in and the fear of being different led some to reject their Chinese culture.

  • Cultural identity was not fixed, with some participants experiencing a fluid and evolving identity.

  • Participants' identities were influenced by their environment, experiences, and interactions.

Theme 2: Connection to the Chinese Culture

  • Language played a significant role in connecting participants to their Chinese heritage.

  • Participants often only engaged with their Chinese culture during holidays or festivals.

  • Some participants reimagined cultural holidays to combine Western and Asian traditions.

  • Concerns about preserving cultural traditions, especially language, were prevalent among participants.

Theme 3: The Role of Online Communities

  • Participants joined online communities to connect with people who shared similar experiences.

  • Some participants actively defended their culture on online platforms, especially in response to rising Asian hate.

  • The desire to resonate with others through shared experiences was a common motivation for joining online communities.

Theme 4: Challenges and Opportunities with Sharing on Online Platforms

  • Participants faced challenges such as backlash and repercussions for sharing cultural heritage content online.

  • As online communities grew, participants found it harder to connect on a personal level.

  • Concerns about maintaining community exclusivity and moderation politics were raised.

  • Participants identified opportunities for social media platforms to better support cultural heritage sharing, including video content and more inclusive platform policies.

Co-design Workshop

Theme 4 was further explored through a workshop with members of the community. 

Admins and Moderation:

  • Participants emphasised the need for moderation rules in online communities to maintain respect and create safe spaces.

  • Admins were considered essential for enforcing moderation rules, as they could understand contextual information and subliminal messages.

  • Concerns were raised about biases among admins, leading to suggestions for having multiple admins with different roles and responsibilities.

  • Admin selection methods varied depending on the community's context and size, with suggestions for democratic elections and consideration of a community's success.

Privacy and Content:

  • Privacy settings in online communities were seen as context-dependent, with public posts suitable for certain content like food and private posts for sensitive information.

  • Participants discussed the importance of properly communicating the scope of content allowed within a community.

  • Suggestions included dividing community sections for different types of content and implementing audience filters to cater to different generations' interests.

  • Options for joining subgroups and sharing professionally produced content were proposed to enhance content diversity and engagement.

Members:

  • Participants believed that online community platforms should only include members of the specific community.

  • Verification methods like asking for personal information were seen as difficult to enforce, and instead, pre-screening questions were suggested.

  • Concerns were expressed about large group sizes hindering close bonds and comfort in sharing, but no limits on group size were recommended.

  • Key features focused on member interactions, including messaging, sharing reactions and experiences, location-based features, and events to facilitate offline interactions and strengthen member connections.

discussion

Challenges with Existing Online Community Platforms for BBCs

  • Difficulty in Forming Connections with Others Online

    • Encourage creative approaches to help biculturals form meaningful connections within online communities.

    • Design features that facilitate smaller sub-communities within larger groups to reduce differences among members.

  • Moderation for ESEA Voices

    • Implement improved moderation strategies to ensure respectful and safe spaces for sharing cultural heritage.

    • Provide moderators and admins with sufficient resources and support for their roles.

Design Opportunities for Communities to Connect and Engage in ICH

  • Creating Sub-communities within Larger Communities

    • Develop features that allow communities to form smaller subgroups based on shared interests, enhancing personalisation and privacy.

  • Community-Created Cultural Archives

    • Implement features that enable users to contribute to shared records of cultural information and preserve cultural heritage collaboratively.

  • Dynamic Moderation:

    • Focus on dynamic moderation strategies that adapt to emerging challenges and changing cultural contexts.

    • Maintain transparency within communities regarding moderation practices.

Interested in reading the full paper? Contact me! 

results and reflections

Project Successes 👏

From the beginning to the end of the project, I was able to take full ownership of the project. I successfully planned, executed and delivered the whole project and received positive feedback from academic staff.

 

What I Learned 🌱

I was able to grow new skills in researching. Since it was the first time I carried out an autoethnography and a workshop, I was able to pick up new skills, particularly workshopping skills.

 

Reflection 🪞

Overall, this project was very rewarding and I believe that I was able to carry out the project successfully. Due to the timeframe and lack of resources, there are several areas that I would like to build upon. Firstly, it was quite challenging to recruit individuals to participate in my project. Reflecting back, it could have been useful to widen my user group to other bicultural individuals. This would have also provided richer data. Since my workshop participants were across the country, it was difficult to carry out an online workshop. I believe that conducting in-person workshops would bring even more value to the project.

bottom of page